“DOGE is a disaster of incompetence.”
That’s how one political scientist responded to Saturday reporting about a Washington state man fighting for his Social Security benefits as U.S. President Donald Trump and the head of his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), billionaire Elon Musk, attack the federal bureaucracy, including the agency that administers payements to seniors like Leonard “Ned” Johnson.
Seattle Times columnist Danny Westneat shared the story of 82-year-old Johnson. In February, his wife received a notification from their bank that the Social Security Administration (SSA) requested a return for benefits paid out after the supposed death of her husband. She figured it was a scam—as Johnson was alive—but the request was real and $5,201 was pulled from their account.
As Westneat detailed, after making multiple calls to SSA, during which Johnson was “put on hold and then eventually disconnected,” and securing an appointment that was ultimately rescheduled for next week, “he went to the office on the ninth floor of the Henry Jackson Federal Building downtown,” one of several sites across the United States that DOGE wants to shut down.
According to the columnist:
After waiting for four hours, Johnson admits he jumped the line: “I saw an opening and I kind of rushed up and told them I was listed as dead. That seemed to get their attention.”
Once in front of a human, Johnson said he was able to quickly prove he was alive, using his passport and his gift of gab. They pledged to fix his predicament, and on Thursday this past week, the bank called to say it had returned the deducted deposits to his account. As of Friday morning he hadn’t received February or March’s benefits payments.
“When I was in that line, I was thinking that if I was living solely off Social Security, I could be close to dumpster diving about now,” he said.
Author Jeff Nesbit, the public affairs chief for five federal agencies or departments—including SSA—under four presidents, shared the article on the Musk-owned social media site X, saying: “So incredibly sad that Musk/DOGE are now preying on people like this. I hope older Americans understand the assault underway against Social Security right now.”
Progressive political consultant Matt Herdman similarly said: “Elon Musk and Donald Trump are stealing seniors’ hard-earned benefits. It’s already happening, and it’ll get worse if they go through with closing branch offices and cutting staff.”
Johnson isn’t the only senior who has had to fight for his Social Security since Trump returned to office in January and installed various billionaires to key positions in the federal government. James McCaffrey, a 66-year-old retiree in Oklahoma City, told his story to NBC affiliate KFOR earlier this week.
McCaffrey learned that his Social Security benefits were suspended when he received a notice saying that he needed to pay $740 or he was going to lose Medicare, health insurance for seniors. After multiple phone calls and hours on hold, he finally got through. He then quickly received the missing payment, but never got an explanation—and SSA refused to give one to the news station.
However, McCaffrey believes his trouble may stem from the fact that he was born on a U.S. military base in Germany—and Musk’s recent Fox Business appearance, during which he claimed that undocumented immigrants are receiving benefits. That came shortly after a podcast interview, during which a billionaire called Social Security a “Ponzi scheme.”
McCaffrey is now concerned about other seniors facing similar issues. As KFOR reported:
He worries about people who may not have the time and resources he had to get to the bottom of what happened and get his benefits back.
“I’ve been a diligent Boy Scout type, I prepared,” he said. “But, no, I shouldn’t have to.”
He also worries about people who may not share the same savings or the same financial cushion [that] he had to fall back on. “And you interrupt that for seven days, two weeks or even longer, and they’re in bad trouble,” he said. “They could be out of the house. They could be out of food. I don’t know.”
In response McCaffrey’s experience, Ashley Schapitl, a public relations professional who previously worked for Senate Democrats and the U.S. Treasury Department, said, “Picture thousands of Social Security beneficiaries having their benefits canceled with no explanation and limited recourse to get them reinstated.”Trump and Musk’s recent moves and remarks have fueled fears that they are working to privatize Social Security.
U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) laid out a potential GOP “attack plan” for the program on X Friday:
One: Trump and his vassals tell lies that there’s no plan to cut Social Security.
Two: Trump and Musk lie loudly about imaginary Social Security “fraud” to lower public confidence in the program.
Three: Musk sends his nasty Musk-rats in to Social Security to damage administration of the fund, leading to “interruption in benefits.”
Four: Trump then declares emergency and hands administration of Social Security to private equity and tech bros to fix problem they created.
Five: Republicans declare victory that they “saved Social Security” by handing it to private equity/tech bros, and put Trump’s name on checks.
The advocacy group Social Security Works took note of Whitehouse’s thread and said: “Everyone needs to read this. Musk and Trump are breaking Social Security so they can turn it over to Wall Street.”
