The EU has flat-out rejected a British demand to end any role for European court judges in Northern Ireland.
Speaking on Wednesday evening the European Commission’s vice president Frans Timmermans said it was “extremely well-known in London” that the demand to ditch the European Court of Justice could not be met.
UK Brexit minister Lord Frost has said the ECJ should be replaced with an independent arbitration panel and that it can have no role settling disputes in Northern Ireland.
But the EU says this is not possible while Northern Ireland is benefitting from being inside the single market. Under the European Union’s founding treaties only the ECJ can interpret EU law.
“I think [Lord] Frost knows very well that this is not possible for the European Union,” Mr Timmermans told ITV’s Peston programme.
“I know he knows full well that whenever the internal market is involved, the ultimate arbitrator is the European Court of Justice.
“This is, I think, extremely well-known in London and instead of talking about red lines, I think it would be more productive to talk about the ideas the European Union came up with.”
The EU chief’s statement is the most explicit yet on the issue of the court, which the bloc has until this point done its best to step around in public.
The UK signed up to the ECJ’s jurisdiction for Northern Ireland when it agreed the protocol two years ago and has only recently started to claim it needs to be scrapped.
Both sides are currently locked in talks to change aspects of the controversial protocol, which has been blamed by unionists, the UK government and others for disrupting trade across the Irish Sea.
The EU last month produced a package of measures to reduce trade checks and form-filling between Northern Ireland and Great Britain – but the UK says it does not go far enough, and has also brought up the largely separate issue of the court. The EU says Northern Irish business leaders do not mention the court as an issue.
Mr Timmermans said the EU’s ideas were “welcomed in Northern Ireland” and would “make things more practicable and easier to deal with”.
“I think those ideas which are meant to make life easier on the business community in Northern Ireland, especially on the citizens on the island of Ireland, should be embraced by the British government, rather than talking about red lines,” he said.
UK news in pictures
Show all 50
UK news in pictures
3 November 2021
Police and demonstrators at a Extinction Rebellion protest on Buchanan Street, during the Cop26 summit in Glasgow
PA
UK news in pictures
2 November 2021
A person walks along the Basingstoke canal near to Dogmersfield in Hampshire
PA
UK news in pictures
1 November 2021
Sir David Attenborough delivers a speech during Cop26 in Glasgow
Reuters
UK news in pictures
31 October 2021
Extinction Rebellion activists protest in Edinburgh as the Cop26 conference begins in Glasgow
Getty
UK news in pictures
30 October 2021
First Minister Nicola Sturgeon with Mapuche leader and Minga Indigena Lead Coordinator Claflin Lafkenche (right) alongside indigenous delegates at a ceremonial gathering at the Tramway in Glasgow in a symbolic gesture to mark a unified demand for climate justice
PA
UK news in pictures
29 October 2021
Ocean Rebellion put on a display of puking oil heads ahead of climate change conference COP26 in Glasgow
EPA
UK news in pictures
28 October 2021
A man dressed as Santa Claus outside Selfridges in London as the department store unveils its Christmas windows on Oxford Street
PA
UK news in pictures
27 October 2021
Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak during a visit to Fourpure Brewery in Bermondsey, London, after the chancellor announced a cut to beer taxes in his budget
PA
UK news in pictures
26 October 2021
Activist Steve Bray demonstrates with a toilet outside the gates of Downing Street, after MPs voted in Parliament against the Environment Bill, allowing companies to pump raw sewage into UK rivers and seas, in London
Reuters
UK news in pictures
25 October 2021
Second World War veteran James White, 96, at the opening of the Edinburgh Garden of Remembrance, marking the start of the remembrance period
PA
UK news in pictures
24 October 2021
Richard Ratcliffe holds up a photo of his wife Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe as he protests outside the Foreign Office while on hunger strike, part of an effort to lobby the UK foreign secretary to bring his wife home from detention in Iran
Getty
UK news in pictures
23 October 2021
Partner of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, Stella Morris and Editor in Chief of WikiLeaks Kristinn Hrafnsson attend a protest ahead of the appeal hearing over Assange’s extradition, in London
Reuters
UK news in pictures
22 October 2021
Palace Gardener Justine Howlett adds the finishing touches to pumpkins bearing the face of Henry VIII and his wives, at Hampton Court Palace.
PA
UK news in pictures
21 October 2021
Flooded fields near Lingfield in Surrey, after southern England was hit overnight by heavy rain and strong winds from Storm Aurore moving in from France
PA
UK news in pictures
20 October 2021
A wing surfer enjoys the strong winds as they surf in the sea off of Hayling Island in Hampshire
PA
UK news in pictures
19 October 2021
Actor Jude Law holds hands with Little Amal, a 3.5-metre-tall puppet of a nine-year-old Syrian girl, as it arrives in Folkestone, Kent, as part of the Handspring Puppet Company’s ‘The Walk’
PA
UK news in pictures
18 October 2021
A view over Southend-on-Sea in Essex, which is set to become a city in tribute to Sir David Amess MP, who spent years campaigning for the change
Getty
UK news in pictures
17 October 2021
Members of the Essex Bangladeshi Welfare Association pay their respects by floral tributes laid at the scene where Sir David Amess MP was killed at Belfairs Methodist Church, in Leigh-on-Sea
Reuters
UK news in pictures
16 October 2021
Boris Johnson, Sir Keir Starmer, Priti Patel and Lindsay Hoyle pay respects to Sir David Amess at Belfairs Methodist Church, in Leigh-on-Sea, the site of his death
EPA
UK news in pictures
15 October 2021
A person lays flowers at the scene near the Belfairs Methodist Church in Eastwood Road North, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, where Conservative MP Sir David Amess has died after he was stabbed several times at a constituency surgery. A man has been arrested and officers are not looking for anyone else
PA
UK news in pictures
14 October 2021
A red deer stag during rutting season in Bushy Park, Richmond, south west London, which is home to over 300 red and fallow deer
PA
UK news in pictures
13 October 2021
Police officers detain a man as Insulate Britain activists block a roundabout at a junction on the M25 motorway during a protest in Thurrock
Reuters
UK news in pictures
12 October 2021
The aerial climate installation by Swiss artivist Dan Acher ‘We Are Watching’ is unveiled at Our Dynamic Earth in Edinburgh
PA
UK news in pictures
10 October 2021
A young girl is helped by a Border Force officer as a group of people thought to be migrants are brought in to Dover, Kent, following a small boat incident in the Channel.
PA
UK news in pictures
9 October 2021
People walk past a life-size sculpture of British singer John Lennon entitled “Imagine”, by sculptor Lawrence Holofcener, displayed to mark what would have been the 81st birthday for the former member of the Beatles in Carnaby Street
Reuters
UK news in pictures
8 October 2021
WW II veteran, 96-year-old Lorna Cockayne, who served in the Women’s Royal Naval Service (WRNS), popularly and officially known as the Wrens, as a Bletchley Park codebreaker, poses for a photograph with the Legion d’honneur after receiving it during a ceremony at the Pear at Parley in Ferndown, Bournemouth
PA
UK news in pictures
7 October 2021
British comedian Jo Brand poses with cut-out silhouettes representing women outside the Metropolitan Police headquarters New Scotland Yard, to highlight violence against women by male police officers or former police officers
AFP via Getty
UK news in pictures
6 October 2021
A protester, wearing a mask of Johnson, holds a sign reading ‘Question it all’ on the final day of the Tory conference
Getty
UK news in pictures
5 October 2021
Members of ‘Insulate Britain’ outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, before a hearing over the injunction banning the environmental activists from blocking the M25
PA
UK news in pictures
4 October 2021
A delegate passes a street cleaner on the second day of the annual Conservative Party Conference being held at the Manchester Central convention centre
AFP via Getty
UK news in pictures
3 October 2021
Margaret Thatcher-themed mugs for sale at the annual Conservative Party conference in Manchester
EPA
UK news in pictures
2 October 2021
A couple make their way through a flooded underpass in Bristol as a yellow weather warning for rain and wind is issued for parts of the UK
Tom Wren/SWNS
UK news in pictures
1 October 2021
A driver talks to members of the media after passing his HGV (Heavy Goods Vehicle) driving test at National Driving Centre in Croydon, south London
AFP via Getty Images
UK news in pictures
30 September 2021
The centrepiece One Thousand Springs by Japanese artist Chiharu Shiota is seen ahead of the beginning of the Japan Festival, a celebration of the country’s plants, art and culture running from 2-31 October, at Kew Gardens in London
PA
UK news in pictures
29 September 2021
The family of Betty Campbell unveil the bronze sculpture of her during the unveiling of the statue in Central Square, Cardiff, of Betty Campbell, Wales’ first black headteacher
PA
UK news in pictures
28 September 2021
A sign referring to the lack of fuel is placed at the entrance to a petrol station in London
AP
UK news in pictures
27 September 2021
Police officers detain a protester from Insulate Britain occupying a roundabout leading from the M25 motorway to Heathrow Airport in London
PA
UK news in pictures
26 September 2021
Labour Party leader Sir Keir Starmer watches the Arsenal v Tottenham Hotspur match at The Font pub in Brighton
PA
UK news in pictures
25 September 2021
Scottish pro-independence supporters hold a march and rally outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh, Scotland
Getty Images
UK news in pictures
24 September 2021
Police officers remove two protesters from the top of a tanker, as Insulate Britain block the A20 in Kent, which provides access to the Port of Dover in Kent. The environmental activists have moved location after been banned from campaigning on the M25 motorway in London
PA
UK news in pictures
23 September 2021
Gabriella, the seven year old daughter of imprisoned British-Iranian Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, joins in a game on a giant snakes and ladders board in Parliament Square, to show the “ups and downs” of her mother’s case to mark the 2,000 days she has been detained in Iran
AP
UK news in pictures
22 September 2021
A new sign hangs on the Millicent Fawcett statue after it was altered by ‘CrackTheCrises’ coalition activists to highlight the climate crisis as a feminist struggle in Parliament Square in London
EPA
UK news in pictures
21 September 2021
Gabriella Diment prepares a monumental bronze patinated fibreglass wall sculpture depicting household cavalry soldiers on horseback which is expected to be sold for £12,000-18,000 when it goes up for auction at Summers Place Auctions in Billinghurst, Kent
PA
UK news in pictures
20 September 2021
Florist Judith Blacklock puts the finishing touches to a floral carousel installation in Halkin Arcade, which she has designed with Neill Strain for the Belgravia in Bloom festival, running from September 20-26, in London
PA
UK news in pictures
19 September 2021
Bubbles surround Manchester United’s Cristiano Ronaldo before the match against West Ham at London Stadium
Action Images/Reuters
UK news in pictures
18 September 2021
Children take part in the Settrington Cup Pedal Car Race as motoring enthusiasts attend the Goodwood Revival, a three-day historic car racing festival in Goodwood, Chichester,
Reuters
UK news in pictures
17 September 2021
Hugo, 7, from London rides past a 4×7 metre rainbow arch, made entirely of recycled aluminium cans, which has been installed by recycling initiative ‘Every Can Counts’, in partnership with The City of London Corporation in front of St Paul’s Cathedral in London, to encourage members of the public to recycle their drinks cans ahead of recycling week, which starts on 20 September
PA
UK news in pictures
16 September 2021
Sheikeh MOhammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, leader of Abu Dhabi, leaves Downing Street after meeting with Boris Johnson
PA
UK news in pictures
15 September 2021
Children pose by ice sculptures depicting people collecting water by charity Water Aid to show the fragility of water and the threat posed by climate change in London
AFP/Getty
UK news in pictures
14 September 2021
Heavy rain covers the A149 near Kings Lynn in Norfolk
PA
Mr Timmermans also said that a solution was “within reach” – though the UK has threatened to trigger Article 16 of the protocol and effectively suspend it.
Asked about the risks of Boris Johnson triggering Article 16 the EU vice president said: “Well you know as Yogi Berra would say, ‘Let’s burn that bridge when we get there.’ Joking aside, let’s hope this doesn’t happen, let’s hope we can find a way out.
“I believe the European Union has shown, the European Commission has shown, clear willingness to find a compromise. I think we’ve been bending over backwards to offer a solution to the practicalities that people encountered in Northern Ireland.
“Let’s focus on the people and the businesses in Northern Ireland instead of trying to score points off each other on certain issues. Let’s try and solve this. I think a solution is within reach.”