In 2024, the world experienced $298 billion in catastrophe losses related to weather events, according to Munich Re, which just released its annual tabulation.
Munich Re attributes the losses to — what else — climate change, dramatically announcing that “climate change is showing its claws” and “climate change is taking its gloves off.” [emphasis, links added]
The Munich Re attribution claim contrasts starkly with how its largest competitor, Swiss Re, characterizes 2024 loss totals, identifying economic development as the “main driver” of increasing loss totals:
“Economic development continues to be the main driver of the rise in insured losses resulting from floods, but also other perils, seen over many decades. However, with natural catastrophe risks rising and higher price levels, the annual increase of 5–7% in insured losses will continue, and protection gaps could remain high. This highlights the need for adaptation in combination with an adequate insurance coverage that can support financial resilience.”
To better understand global disaster losses, it is helpful to place them into the context of the global economy, which like the climate, also changes over time.
The methodology and data are described in detail in this 2019 paper:
Pielke, Jr. R. (2019). Tracking progress on the economic costs of disasters under the indicators of the sustainable development goals. Environmental Hazards, 18(1), 1-6.
The figure below updates the time series of Munich Re’s disaster loss record as a proportion of global GDP.
Losses in 2024 were about 0.26% of global GDP, similar to 2021 and 2022, much lower than 2005 and 2017, and higher than 2018, 2019, and 2023.
Since 1990, the overall trend has been down — from about 0.25% of GDP in 1990 to about 0.20% in 2024. In the 1990s catastrophe losses as a proportion of GDP exceeding those of 2024 were common.
The data in this graph is good news — regarding economic losses, extreme weather has less impact today than it did 35 years ago.
Last fall, Verisk published an estimate of expected global insured losses (specifically, AAL or average annual loss) of $151 billion.
If we double that, as is common practice to estimate overall (insured and uninsured) losses, we get $302 billion, which is almost exactly the actual loss total for 2024.
Losses in 2024, at about $300 billion, were large — but not at all unexpected or unusual.
Verisk’s 2023 average annual loss estimate was $133 billion — meaning that expected insured losses jumped by $18 billion in just one year, from 2023 to 2024.
Bill Churney, President of Verisk’s extreme event solutions, attributes this alarming surge in catastrophe losses to several key factors.
The primary drivers include the growth in exposure values, fueled by ongoing construction in high-hazard areas, and rising replacement costs due to inflation.
While climate change is often cited as a factor, Churney emphasizes that year-over-year increases in exposure and replacement values exert a more immediate impact.
Verisk expects continued exposure growth of 7.2% per year, which means insured losses will continue to mount. Verisk explains:
“While actual annual insured losses over the past five years have been high, averaging $106 billion, they should not be seen as outliers.
“Our models show the insurance industry should be prepared to experience total annual insured losses from natural catastrophes of $151 billion on average, and well more than that in large loss years.”
That exposure growth is driving increasing disaster losses is not at all surprising.
The figure below shows that over the past decade, expected insured catastrophe losses have more than doubled (from ~$70B in 2014 to ~$151 in 2024).
While some promote climate change as the main factor behind increasing losses, Swiss Re acknowledges that it has not yet seen a signal of climate change in losses, even as climate change presents future risks:
“To date, growth in natural catastrophe-related property losses has been mostly driven by rising exposures due to economic growth, accumulation of asset values, urbanisation and rising populations, often in regions susceptible to severe weather events (eg, coastal regions, river fronts and wildland-urban interfaces).
“In the future, hazard intensification due to climate change is set to add to weather-related losses.”
Read rest at The Honest Broker
The Honest Broker is written by climate expert Roger Pielke Jr and is reader-supported. If you value what you have read here, please consider subscribing and supporting the work that goes into it.
