• About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie policy (EU)
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Video
  • Write for us
Today Headline
  • HOME
  • NEWS
    • POLITICS
    • News for today
    • Borisov news
  • FINANCE
    • Business
    • Insurance
  • Video
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • ENTERPRISE
  • LIFESTYLE
    • TRAVEL
    • HEALTH
    • ENTERTAINMENT
  • AUTOMOTIVE
  • SPORTS
  • Travel and Tourism
  • HOME
  • NEWS
    • POLITICS
    • News for today
    • Borisov news
  • FINANCE
    • Business
    • Insurance
  • Video
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • ENTERPRISE
  • LIFESTYLE
    • TRAVEL
    • HEALTH
    • ENTERTAINMENT
  • AUTOMOTIVE
  • SPORTS
  • Travel and Tourism
No Result
View All Result
TodayHeadline
No Result
View All Result

Divestment or engagement: can responsible investing change corporate behaviour? | The invested generation

February 12, 2022
in Business
0
Divestment or engagement: can responsible investing change corporate behaviour? | The invested generation
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


It has become a key debate for responsible investors. Should shareholders sell their stake in companies that fall short on ethical or environmental issues, or should they instead retain their holding and use their position as stakeholders to put pressure on companies to do better?

The debate is often couched as the “divestment versus engagement” dilemma. Unlike ethical consumerism, responsible investing isn’t as simple as conscientiously substituting items in your shopping basket for more sustainable or ethical alternatives. For a start, there will likely be less scrupulous investors out there happy to take your place. “Ditching and switching” can therefore all too often entail offloading polluting assets to less accountable or responsible owners.

Second, divesting in heavily polluting companies can make it harder for them to raise funds to finance the transition to cleaner ways of operating. So, although divestment might seem like the ultimate sanction for punishing badly behaving companies, it may not always produce the most effective results.

Engagement is more nuanced. It’s a broader approach that can range from directly discussing concerns with a company to more high-profile and confrontational measures, such as tabling shareholder votes on environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues at annual company meetings. When shareholders publicly criticise companies, it can make media headlines and increase pressure on a company to act. Whichever form the engagement takes, by retaining a seat at the table and agitating for change, investors can wield not just formidable financial power, but also an influential voice.

Shareholder engagement is usually done by asset managers who invest and manage investment funds on behalf of individual investors and pension holders. It often involves compromise and detailed discussions, and it can require time and perseverance. “It’s almost like a [dance] choreography with the investor coming from one corner of the room and the management in the other,” says Carlota Garcia-Manas, head of engagement within the responsible investing team at Royal London Asset Management, which is part of Royal London Group. “Both sides work to improve the long-term performance of the company. Both almost always compromise.”

Two people with large speech bubbles overlapping like Venn diagram

There are strong opinions on both sides of the engagement versus divestment debate. Many climate activists have been urging shareholders to fully divest from fossil fuel companies, for instance. Others feel it’s important to be able to influence them. “To really move the needle [on ESG matters] you need to be more forward-thinking and see the bigger picture, which is about making the world a better place,” says Matthew Burgess, head of quantitative equities at Royal London Asset Management. “If you can’t hold investments in [certain companies], how can you engage and make them better?”

Some experts suggest that framing it as an either-or dilemma is an oversimplification – pointing out that the two approaches can often work better if they are used together. Divestment can be employed as a last resort that strengthens the position of shareholders during discussions. Nonetheless, the debate can be helpful for understanding why engagement can often be an effective way of investing responsibly.

Research published earlier this year by the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance suggests that shareholder engagement can improve companies’ ESG ratings and bring better financial returns for shareholders when different shareholders co-ordinate their engagement – especially if a lead investor heads the dialogue.

Likewise, a study published in 2020 by professors at the universities of Trento, Harvard and Chicago, found that “exit is less effective than voice in pushing firms to act in a socially responsible manner”.

John Fleetwood, director of responsible and sustainable investing at Square Mile, an investment research and consulting company, says that it can be difficult to prove “cause and effect” between shareholder engagement and companies behaving more ethically due to the limited information that is published about discussions. “A lot of engagement is behind closed doors,” he says.

However, more and more information on shareholder engagement is becoming publicly available – which can help investors choose which asset managers to entrust with their money. Many asset managers publish regular updates on their engagement with the companies their funds invest in and their ESG ratings. In addition, not-for-profit shareholder activist groups, such as the UK’s ShareAction, provide a valuable service ranking the world’s largest investors, banks and insurers based on their ESG performance, such as the that they vote on ESG resolutions at annual meetings.

These activist groups often combine with individual and institutional shareholders and fund managers to lobby companies and table votes or resolutions at annual company meetings.

This kind of co-ordinated action can amplify the power that comes with retaining a stake and engaging. Climate Action 100+, for instance, is a group representing investors who collectively manage assets worth about $60tn (£44.5tn) and it is in discussions with some of the world’s largest corporate greenhouse gas emitters to encourage them to take necessary action on climate change. Such groups also lobby policy makers and regulators to encourage responsible investment.

“Often the collective [shareholder] engagement has more impact than the individual [engagement],” says Fleetwood.

Earlier this year, Follow This, a Dutch shareholder campaign group, tabled a resolution at Shell’s AGM, calling on the oil company to set more ambitious targets for cutting emissions. Although the resolution didn’t pass, about one third of shareholders supported it, and it got widespread media attention.

More dramatically, a group of shareholders teamed up with the activist hedge fund Engine No 1 earlier this year to oust three board members at ExxonMobil over the oil group’s slow progress on climate issues. The three positions were instead filled by Engine No 1 nominees.

Of course, had they taken the seemingly drastic step of divesting, they would not have been able to engage so effectively.

Learn more about responsible investing by heading to Royal London – The Invested Generation

Tags: behaviourCHANGEcorporateDivestmentEngagementGenerationinvestedInvestingresponsible
Previous Post

Israel Adesanya vs Robert Whittaker, how to watch, start time, preview, champion, middleweight, new deal

Next Post

Elden Ring: Starting Stats and Equipment For Every Class

Related Posts

Business

‘The Chosen One’ producers, Netflix comment on actor deaths

In their first public comments...

Read more
Business

Aegis share: Multibagger in making: Nomura says this logistic stock may double in 12 months!

NEW DELHI: Nomura India says...

Read more
Business

Biden says G7 must stick together as gold sanctions target Putin’s ‘war machine’ By Reuters

4/4 © Reuters. U.S. President...

Read more
Business

Why Instagram Is a Powerful Tool For Entrepreneurs

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors...

Read more
Business

I’m a fashion expert and my seven super easy styling hacks can completely transform your look and make you look slimmer

IF YOU feel as though...

Read more
Load More
Next Post
Elden Ring: Starting Stats and Equipment For Every Class

Elden Ring: Starting Stats and Equipment For Every Class

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Kenosha Journalist Arrested for Telling Cop He Has a Small Dick

Kenosha Journalist Arrested for Telling Cop He Has a Small Dick

Depraved child abusers face life in jail under new law named after boy who lost legs following torture by sick parents

Three decomposing bodies found in home after being tied up with cords, locked in basement and brutally stabbed

‘These are not my ideal living arrangements’: My husband and I live in his mother’s home. She will leave it to him when she dies. Do I have a claim on this home?

The Biggest News From Summer Game Fest 2022 And The Other June Showcases

Kilwinning: Theresa Potter charity tournament raises £2,280

Total Warrior Leeds: Photo highlights from the Great Northern Mud Run 2022

Is Real Estate Still an Option?

About Us

Todayheadline the independent news and topics discovery
A home-grown and independent news and topic aggregation . displays breaking news linking to news websites all around the world.

Follow Us

Latest News

The Biggest News From Summer Game Fest 2022 And The Other June Showcases

Kilwinning: Theresa Potter charity tournament raises £2,280

The Biggest News From Summer Game Fest 2022 And The Other June Showcases

Kilwinning: Theresa Potter charity tournament raises £2,280

Total Warrior Leeds: Photo highlights from the Great Northern Mud Run 2022

  • Real Estate
  • Education
  • Parenting
  • Cooking
  • Travel and Tourism
  • Home & Garden
  • Pets
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • About

© 2021 All rights are reserved Todayheadline

No Result
View All Result
  • Real Estate
  • Education
  • Parenting
  • Cooking
  • Travel and Tourism
  • Home & Garden
  • Pets
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
  • About

© 2021 All rights are reserved Todayheadline

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist