The Renewable Energy Illusion
Modern society depends on continuous, reliable electricity not only for lighting and appliances but also for transportation, industrial production, communication, and the maintenance of public health systems. [emphasis, links added]
From the cooling of vaccines and surgical procedures to the operation of telecommunications networks, the constant availability of power is essential.
Wind and solar simply cannot fulfill all these roles without substantial backup from other electricity-generating sources, primarily coal, natural gas, or nuclear power.
Even in regions rich in wind or solar potential, seasonal variations and extended periods of calm or cloudiness create substantial supply vulnerabilities.
Electricity, while vital, is only one component of our vast energy ecosystem that includes transportation fuels, products, and electricity. Fossil fuels do far more than power homes — they are the foundational input for countless products and infrastructure systems.
From the fuels that power our cars and planes to the plastics used in hospitals and data centers, hydrocarbons remain deeply embedded in the global economy.
Industrial processes, such as steel production, cement manufacturing, and petrochemical refining, all rely on fossil fuels not only for electricity but also as feedstocks of the products made from oil derivatives manufactured from raw crude oil.
Ignoring this complexity in favor of simplistic narratives undermines our ability to build practical, balanced electricity strategies for the future. It also risks creating policies that disrupt critical sectors, jeopardize economic growth, and overlook the needs of poorer developing regions still struggling with access to electricity.
What Fossil Fuels Provide
Fossil fuels are the backbone of modern life. Over 6,000 essential products — from medical tools and electronics to fertilizers and plastics — are derived from petroleum.
These include everyday items such as clothing, packaging, synthetic rubber, detergents, cosmetics, and even medications. Without fossil fuels, modern healthcare, sanitation, and transportation systems would cease to function effectively.
Global transportation, including over a billion vehicles and tens of thousands of aircraft and ships, relies on oil-based transportation fuels made from crude oil.
These fuels are energy-dense, portable, and economically efficient — qualities that current renewable technologies cannot match. Replacing them with alternatives would require new materials not yet available in the required volumes.
Hospitals, agriculture, and digital infrastructure also depend on fossil fuel-based products and electricity. Operating rooms require sterile plastic instruments. Farms rely on diesel-powered machinery and nitrogen-based fertilizers derived from natural gas.
Data centers, which power the digital economy, require continuous energy and equipment built with fossil-fuel-derived components.
These uses cannot be easily or economically replaced, especially in developing regions still building foundational infrastructure.
Limits of Wind and Solar
Wind and solar depend on weather and daylight. They can’t produce baseload power consistently and need fossil fuel or nuclear-generated electricity as backup.
Even when the sun shines and the wind blows, electricity storage becomes essential for nighttime or cloudy days and still air. Unfortunately, large-scale battery systems are expensive, environmentally challenging to produce, and limited in capacity.
The infrastructure supporting wind and solar turbines, panels, and batteries relies on mining, manufacturing, and transport powered by oil and gas.
Materials such as rare earth elements, copper, steel, and aluminum must be extracted, refined, and delivered — tasks currently dependent on the products and transportation fuels from fossil fuels.
The environmental footprint of this entire supply chain must be factored into any honest assessment of renewables.
Electric vehicles may reduce emissions at the tailpipe, but still rely on fossil fuels for manufacturing, electricity, and maintenance. Battery production is electricity-intensive and involves supply chains often associated with poor labor practices and ecological disruption.
Battery storage remains costly and insufficient for meeting large-scale needs, particularly in cold climates or during prolonged periods of low renewable energy output. Meanwhile, the electricity used to charge EVs is often still generated by fossil fuels.
The Risk of Rushed Net-Zero Goals
Eliminating fossil fuels without practical alternatives risks societal regression. Billions depend on hydrocarbons for basic development.
In many parts of the world, fossil fuels are still the most accessible and affordable source of electricity for cooking, heating, and transportation. Removing that access too quickly could worsen poverty and health outcomes.
Europe’s electricity crises show the dangers of overdependence on renewables and geopolitical instability. Several countries that phased out fossil fuels prematurely had to restart coal-fired power plants to avoid blackouts.
The global scramble for LNG further demonstrates the fragility of current energy systems and the unintended consequences of rapid decarbonization.
Investment policies that shun fossil fuels often cause underinvestment in electricity infrastructure, raising the risk of shortages and economic instability. Divestment campaigns may satisfy political goals, but rarely consider technical feasibility.
A more balanced approach is needed — one that combines emissions reduction with electricity security and technological realism.
Read rest at America Out Loud
