• Education
    • Higher Education
    • Scholarships & Grants
    • Online Learning
    • School Reforms
    • Research & Innovation
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Food & Drink
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Home & Living
    • Relationships & Family
  • Technology & Startups
    • Software & Apps
    • Startup Success Stories
    • Startups & Innovations
    • Tech Regulations
    • Venture Capital
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cybersecurity
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Gadgets & Devices
    • Industry Analysis
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy
Today Headline
  • Home
  • World News
    • Us & Canada
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Middle East
  • Politics
    • Elections
    • Political Parties
    • Government Policies
    • International Relations
    • Legislative News
  • Business & Finance
    • Market Trends
    • Stock Market
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Corporate News
    • Economic Policies
  • Science & Environment
    • Space Exploration
    • Climate Change
    • Wildlife & Conservation
    • Environmental Policies
    • Medical Research
  • Health
    • Public Health
    • Mental Health
    • Medical Breakthroughs
    • Fitness & Nutrition
    • Pandemic Updates
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • Motorsport
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV & Streaming
    • Celebrity News
    • Awards & Festivals
  • Crime & Justice
    • Court Cases
    • Cybercrime
    • Policing
    • Criminal Investigations
    • Legal Reforms
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World News
    • Us & Canada
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Middle East
  • Politics
    • Elections
    • Political Parties
    • Government Policies
    • International Relations
    • Legislative News
  • Business & Finance
    • Market Trends
    • Stock Market
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Corporate News
    • Economic Policies
  • Science & Environment
    • Space Exploration
    • Climate Change
    • Wildlife & Conservation
    • Environmental Policies
    • Medical Research
  • Health
    • Public Health
    • Mental Health
    • Medical Breakthroughs
    • Fitness & Nutrition
    • Pandemic Updates
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • Motorsport
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV & Streaming
    • Celebrity News
    • Awards & Festivals
  • Crime & Justice
    • Court Cases
    • Cybercrime
    • Policing
    • Criminal Investigations
    • Legal Reforms
No Result
View All Result
Today Headline
No Result
View All Result
Home World News Asia

Did Indonesia Just Capitulate to China on the South China Sea? – The Diplomat

November 12, 2024
in Asia
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Did Indonesia Just Capitulate to China on the South China Sea?
18
SHARES
40
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Indonesia has been forced to clarify that it does not recognize China’s maximalist claims over the South China Sea, after signing a maritime development deal with Beijing that appears to acknowledge Beijing’s “nine-dash line” claim.

A joint statement issued on Saturday during Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto’s visit to Beijing mentioned that the two countries had “reached important common understanding on joint development in areas of overlapping claims.” It said that the two sides had agreed to set up an Inter-Governmental Joint Steering Committee to manage the development, “pursuant to their respective prevailing laws and regulations.”

Due to their outstanding maritime disputes with China in the South China Sea, rival claimant states – the Philippines, Vietnam, Brunei, Malaysia, and Taiwan – have generally avoided agreeing to any joint development agreement with China. The fear is that this could be interpreted as a formal recognition of China’s expansive claims over the vital waterway.

The release of the joint statement was interpreted by some South China Sea watchers as marking a (perhaps unwitting) break from a long-standing Indonesian policy.

While China insists that Indonesia’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) and continental shelf around the Natuna Islands overlaps with the “nine-dash line,” Indonesia’s Foreign Ministry has long rejected the Chinese claim, and does not acknowledge that it has any overlapping jurisdiction with China. For this reason, it officially considers itself a non-claimant state in the South China Sea and, under the United National Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), is entitled to sovereign rights over its EEZ around the Natuna Islands, and exclusive access to the resources that lie within it.

The implicit acknowledgment of “overlapping claims” appears to undermine this position. Collin Koh of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies wrote yesterday on X that the agreement appeared to mark a retreat from Indonesia’s stance that it is not a claimant in the South China Sea. He said that this constitutes “nothing less than a historic victory for Beijing.”

In an article for the Lowy Institute’s Interpreter blog, Aristyo Rizka Darmawan of Universitas Indonesia argued that by agreeing to the joint statement with China, the new Indonesian administration had become “the first ASEAN member-state to implicitly recognize Beijing’s ‘nine-dash line.’” In so doing, Indonesia appears to have  “betrayed Indonesia’s national interest” and handed Beijing a “big win.”

In a statement yesterday, Indonesia’s Foreign Ministry rushed to clarify that its position was unchanged and that Saturday’s agreement would have no impact on its sovereignty over the area that it terms the North Natuna Sea.

“Indonesia reiterates its position that [China’s] claim has no basis in international law and is not in accordance with UNCLOS 1982,” it stated. “The cooperation has no impact on Indonesia’s sovereignty, sovereign rights, or jurisdiction in the North Natuna Sea.”

The Ministry stated that the proposed cooperation agreement with China would cover “various aspects of economic cooperation, especially in the field of fisheries and fisheries conservation in the region.” The trust generated thereby would help push forward negotiations on the long-delayed ASEAN-China Code of Conduct for the South China Sea.

Exactly how this impacts Indonesia’s position around the Natuna Islands remains unclear – as one observer noted today, the reference to “prevailing laws and regulations” could lead to the agreement being blocked in the Indonesian legislature – but at the very least it has created a host of probably unwelcome complications for the Foreign Ministry.

In his article for the Lowy Institute, Aristyo argued that far from helping ASEAN negotiate a Code of Conduct with China it might complicate the process, given the apparent break in Jakarta’s long-standing policy that all claims in the Code should be based on a legitimate claim under UNCLOS. He said the move could also potentially affect the Indonesia-Vietnam EEZ delimitation agreement that was signed in late 2022.

Given the Foreign Ministry’s consistency up until this point, it is hard to avoid the conclusion that all of this was an unforced error by a green and untested administration. When Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto took office last month, he appointed Sugiono, the deputy chairperson of his Gerindra Party, as foreign minister in his sprawling cabinet. A political novice who only entered national politics in 2019, the 45-year-old came to the post with little hands-on experience in foreign affairs. In this respect, he differs dramatically from his predecessor Retno Marsudi, a career diplomat who had nearly two decades of experience in the diplomatic corps before her appointment as foreign minister in 2014.

In the end, the Indonesian move may represent less a conscious shift in policy than a cautionary tale about the perils of turning a nation’s foreign relations into a political sinecure. Bill Hayton of Chatham House, the author of a 2014 book on the South China Sea, said in a post on X that the statement was “starting to look like a giant mistake by a very inexperienced foreign minister.”

Whatever the cause, it seems as if the staff at the Foreign Ministry now have an almighty mess on their hands, and cleaning it up could well reignite the South China Sea question in China-Indonesia relations. Despite the Indonesian government’s clarification, Aristyo wrote, “China may continue to hold the interpretation presented in the earlier statement.” This could have uncertain impacts on the relationship between Jakarta and Beijing.

Previous Post

Russia and China must counter any U.S. attempt at containment, Shoigu says

Next Post

What is the latest science on climate change? By Reuters

Related Posts

Suriname's Parliament elects country's first female President amid economic turmoil

Suriname’s Parliament elects country’s first female President amid economic turmoil

July 6, 2025
1
FILE PHOTO: An excavator moves earth next to a hole in the ground at a poultry farm after Brazil confirmed its first outbreak of bird flu on Friday, triggering protocols for a country-wide trade ban from top buyer China and state-wide restrictions for other major consumers, in Montenegro, Brazil May 16, 2025. REUTERS/Diego Vara/File Photo

China studies resuming chicken imports from Brazil, minister says

July 6, 2025
4
Next Post
What is the latest science on climate change? By Reuters

What is the latest science on climate change? By Reuters

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Family calls for change after B.C. nurse dies by suicide after attacks on the job

Family calls for change after B.C. nurse dies by suicide after attacks on the job

April 2, 2025
Pioneering 3D printing project shares successes

Product reduces TPH levels to non-hazardous status

November 27, 2024

Police ID man who died after Corso Italia fight

December 23, 2024

Hospital Mergers Fail to Deliver Better Care or Lower Costs, Study Finds todayheadline

December 31, 2024
Harris tells supporters 'never give up' and urges peaceful transfer of power

Harris tells supporters ‘never give up’ and urges peaceful transfer of power

0
Des Moines Man Accused Of Shooting Ex-Girlfriend's Mother

Des Moines Man Accused Of Shooting Ex-Girlfriend’s Mother

0

Trump ‘looks forward’ to White House meeting with Biden

0
Catholic voters were critical to Donald Trump’s blowout victory: ‘Harris snubbed us’

Catholic voters were critical to Donald Trump’s blowout victory: ‘Harris snubbed us’

0
A pie chart printed on a piece of paper.

Billionaire Bill Ackman Has 51% of His Hedge Fund’s $14.4 Billion Portfolio Invested in Just 3 Exceptional Stocks todayheadline

July 6, 2025
First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say

First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say todayheadline

July 6, 2025

EV Fast Chargers Create Pollution Hot Spots todayheadline

July 6, 2025
Vehicles sit submerged as a search and rescue worker looks through debris for any survivors.

Texas flood highlights deadly climate risk at crucial moment

July 6, 2025

Recent News

A pie chart printed on a piece of paper.

Billionaire Bill Ackman Has 51% of His Hedge Fund’s $14.4 Billion Portfolio Invested in Just 3 Exceptional Stocks todayheadline

July 6, 2025
2
First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say

First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say todayheadline

July 6, 2025
3

EV Fast Chargers Create Pollution Hot Spots todayheadline

July 6, 2025
5
Vehicles sit submerged as a search and rescue worker looks through debris for any survivors.

Texas flood highlights deadly climate risk at crucial moment

July 6, 2025
2

TodayHeadline is a dynamic news website dedicated to delivering up-to-date and comprehensive news coverage from around the globe.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Basketball
  • Business & Finance
  • Climate Change
  • Crime & Justice
  • Cybersecurity
  • Economic Policies
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Environmental Policies
  • Europe
  • Football
  • Gadgets & Devices
  • Health
  • Medical Research
  • Mental Health
  • Middle East
  • Motorsport
  • Olympics
  • Politics
  • Public Health
  • Relationships & Family
  • Science & Environment
  • Software & Apps
  • Space Exploration
  • Sports
  • Stock Market
  • Technology & Startups
  • Tennis
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • Us & Canada
  • Wildlife & Conservation
  • World News

Recent News

A pie chart printed on a piece of paper.

Billionaire Bill Ackman Has 51% of His Hedge Fund’s $14.4 Billion Portfolio Invested in Just 3 Exceptional Stocks todayheadline

July 6, 2025
First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say

First indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks ended inconclusively, Palestinian sources say todayheadline

July 6, 2025
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
  • Technology & Startups
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2024 Todayheadline.co

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Business & Finance
  • Corporate News
  • Economic Policies
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Market Trends
  • Crime & Justice
  • Court Cases
  • Criminal Investigations
  • Cybercrime
  • Legal Reforms
  • Policing
  • Education
  • Higher Education
  • Online Learning
  • Entertainment
  • Awards & Festivals
  • Celebrity News
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Health
  • Fitness & Nutrition
  • Medical Breakthroughs
  • Mental Health
  • Pandemic Updates
  • Lifestyle
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Food & Drink
  • Home & Living
  • Politics
  • Elections
  • Government Policies
  • International Relations
  • Legislative News
  • Political Parties
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Europe
  • Middle East
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cybersecurity
  • Emerging Technologies
  • Gadgets & Devices
  • Industry Analysis
  • Basketball
  • Football
  • Motorsport
  • Olympics
  • Climate Change
  • Environmental Policies
  • Medical Research
  • Science & Environment
  • Space Exploration
  • Wildlife & Conservation
  • Sports
  • Tennis
  • Technology & Startups
  • Software & Apps
  • Startup Success Stories
  • Startups & Innovations
  • Tech Regulations
  • Venture Capital
  • Uncategorized
  • World News
  • Us & Canada
  • Public Health
  • Relationships & Family
  • Travel
  • Research & Innovation
  • Scholarships & Grants
  • School Reforms
  • Stock Market
  • TV & Streaming
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy
  • About us
  • Contact

© 2024 Todayheadline.co