• Education
    • Higher Education
    • Scholarships & Grants
    • Online Learning
    • School Reforms
    • Research & Innovation
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Food & Drink
    • Fashion & Beauty
    • Home & Living
    • Relationships & Family
  • Technology & Startups
    • Software & Apps
    • Startup Success Stories
    • Startups & Innovations
    • Tech Regulations
    • Venture Capital
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cybersecurity
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Gadgets & Devices
    • Industry Analysis
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy
Today Headline
  • Home
  • World News
    • Us & Canada
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Middle East
  • Politics
    • Elections
    • Political Parties
    • Government Policies
    • International Relations
    • Legislative News
  • Business & Finance
    • Market Trends
    • Stock Market
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Corporate News
    • Economic Policies
  • Science & Environment
    • Space Exploration
    • Climate Change
    • Wildlife & Conservation
    • Environmental Policies
    • Medical Research
  • Health
    • Public Health
    • Mental Health
    • Medical Breakthroughs
    • Fitness & Nutrition
    • Pandemic Updates
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • Motorsport
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV & Streaming
    • Celebrity News
    • Awards & Festivals
  • Crime & Justice
    • Court Cases
    • Cybercrime
    • Policing
    • Criminal Investigations
    • Legal Reforms
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World News
    • Us & Canada
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • Middle East
  • Politics
    • Elections
    • Political Parties
    • Government Policies
    • International Relations
    • Legislative News
  • Business & Finance
    • Market Trends
    • Stock Market
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Corporate News
    • Economic Policies
  • Science & Environment
    • Space Exploration
    • Climate Change
    • Wildlife & Conservation
    • Environmental Policies
    • Medical Research
  • Health
    • Public Health
    • Mental Health
    • Medical Breakthroughs
    • Fitness & Nutrition
    • Pandemic Updates
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Basketball
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
    • Motorsport
  • Entertainment
    • Movies
    • Music
    • TV & Streaming
    • Celebrity News
    • Awards & Festivals
  • Crime & Justice
    • Court Cases
    • Cybercrime
    • Policing
    • Criminal Investigations
    • Legal Reforms
No Result
View All Result
Today Headline
No Result
View All Result
Home World News Us & Canada

Christopher Dummitt: | National Post

November 18, 2024
in Us & Canada
Reading Time: 11 mins read
A A
0
2
SHARES
4
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Breadcrumb Trail Links

  1. NP Comment

Patrice Dutil’s new book paints Macdonald as a man confronted on all sides trying to quell rebellion and discontent

Published Nov 18, 2024  •  Last updated 1 hour ago  •  6 minute read

You can save this article by registering for free here. Or sign-in if you have an account.

Sir John A. Macdonald. Photo by Library and Archives Canada

Article content

In the conclusion to his magisterial new book, “Sir. John A. Macdonald and the Apocalyptic Year 1885,†historian Patrice Dutil laments the posthumous fate of Canadaâ€s founding prime minister John A. Macdonald. “Itâ€s hard to imagine,†Dutil says, “a reputation being trashed so hatefully, so suddenly and so thoroughly.â€

And yet, this is exactly what has happened. Across the country, cities have removed Macdonaldâ€s statues, and mobs regularly deface those that remain. Whether it is the names of pubs or law schools — those in authority have decided to dishonour John A. Macdonald — to remove him from a place of public prominence.

Advertisement 2

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS

Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

  • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
  • Unlimited online access to National Post and 15 news sites with one account.
  • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
  • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
  • Support local journalism.

SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES

Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

  • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
  • Unlimited online access to National Post and 15 news sites with one account.
  • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
  • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
  • Support local journalism.

REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES

Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

  • Access articles from across Canada with one account.
  • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments.
  • Enjoy additional articles per month.
  • Get email updates from your favourite authors.

THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK.

Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

  • Access articles from across Canada with one account
  • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments
  • Enjoy additional articles per month
  • Get email updates from your favourite authors

Don’t have an account? Create Account

or

Article content

Whatâ€s most striking for a historian to see in these attacks — in the fierce anger of the crowds or the more toned-down sombre apologies of the officials — is the extent to which these attacks all depend on a disturbing trio of traits: parochialism, ignorance and ideological zeal.

The case against Macdonald largely requires you not to care about the intricate details of the past and, if you do, to interpret them only as would a crown prosecutor, not someone who was genuinely trying to understand life in that foreign country that is history. It requires you to look largely at only Canada, and, even then, to not contemplate the values and norms of his era. And the moralizing prosecution is carried out most strenuously by radicals who would find fault with just about anything done by someone they see as just another dead white man.

Patrice Dutilâ€s new book takes an entirely different approach. He wants us to walk in the shoes of Macdonald through one pivotal year: 1885.

It was a consequential year in ways both familiar and forgotten. It was the year of Mark Twainâ€s “Huckleberry Finnâ€; of Louis Pasteur first vaccinating a child against rabies; of the establishment of Greenwich Mean Time. The year 1885 was the year of the second Louis Riel rebellion as well as the completion of the Canadian Pacific Railway. It was also a year of disease — of a smallpox outbreak that killed thousands. It was the year when empire loyalists demanded revenge for the death of Gen. Gordon in Khartoum. Canadaâ€s international trade was on the block in the midst of a severe recession, and Canadaâ€s treaty with the United States regulating the fisheries was set to expire. It was a year when Macdonald attempted to expand the franchise, to allow women, status Indians and a larger segment of the working class to vote.

Platformed

This newsletter tackles hot topics with boldness, verve and wit. (Subscriber-exclusive edition on Fridays)

By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc.

We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again

Article content

Advertisement 3

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content

Macdonald emerges as a man confronted on all sides — with battles between Catholics and Protestants, calls to push Canada further into empire affairs, demands from British Columbians for harsher treatment against Chinese-Canadians and contradictory demands from Liberal critics who wanted him to spend almost nothing on Indigenous-Canadians and then blamed him for not doing enough to prevent rebellion and discontent.

This is a must-read book for anyone who has accepted at face value the criticism of Macdonald that have developed over the last few years.

Dutil lays bare some of the more ludicrous attacks that have been, in too many circles, taken at face value. Notably, there is the idea that Macdonald led a policy of genocide that attempted to starve the Plains Indians into submission in the 1880s. This idea gained publicity with the publication of James Daschukâ€s book “Clearing the Plains: Disease, Politics of Starvation, and the Loss of Indigenous Life.†Dutil examines the case that has been drawn out of that book and lays bare its feeble foundations. Macdonald is said to have set policies that starved Indigenous peoples on the plains who were suffering from the effects of the decline of the buffalo. The broader phenomenon is accurate — the disappearance of the buffalo from the plain was a horrendous cultural and nutritional disaster for those who had relied on the hunt for survival.

Advertisement 4

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content

Yet, when Dutil starts counting — asking how many people died and why — what becomes evident is that Daschukâ€s book largely relied on generalizations based on only a handful of cases. Dutil finds in Daschukâ€s book records of only 65 people who are said to have died in the key “starvation years†from 1879 to 1884 — and of these, 20 died of food poisoning. These deaths also largely occurred in the communities led by the two chiefs (Piapot and Big Bear) who most resisted Macdonaldâ€s policy — who held out on signing treaties and taking up reserves. What Dutil shows is that Macdonaldâ€s government spent huge sums of money trying to send food west — spending more on Indian affairs than almost any other aspect of government.

Whatâ€s more, it was precisely a desire to assist Indigenous peoples to shift towards an agricultural lifestyle — where they could feed themselves on the Prairies without the buffalo — that lay behind the other kinds of assimilation measures like residential schools, that are also now derided and attacked as “genocidal.†What Dutil does is expose the hard choices that lay behind a policy that had such terrible consequences, letting readers understand the political logic behind it.

Advertisement 5

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content

“History is a tragedy, not a morality tale†is the fitting quotation from I.F. Stone that Dutil sets above his conclusion. There is much that is tragic about 1885 and the kinds of policies that Macdonald and others put in place. There is much that we might now find offensive — the common sensical race talk of the late 19th century, or the surety with which Macdonald and others spoke of civilization. And yet, there is also much to learn from taking this world — and the ideas of those who actually lived in 1885 — at face value — and trying to understand them for what they were.

For one thing — we will be surprised. Weâ€ll be surprised to see Macdonald promoting a new bill to extend the franchise to women property owners, decades before women would eventually come to have the vote in most western countries. Macdonald lowered voting qualifications for working-class men and wanted to give women the vote as well as Indigenous peoples who met the same property qualifications. When his Liberal opponents criticized his desire to include Indigenous peoples as voters, he argued that Indians were “just as fit, as far as intellect goes, as far as education goes, as far as having an interest in the prosperity of the country goes, as their white brethren.†To deny them the right to vote was an “injustice.†When the vote for status Indians in Eastern Canada finally passed, he called it “the greatest triumph of (his) lifeâ€

Advertisement 6

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content

There is, of course, much more in the book. Dutil sets the conflict in Western Canada in an international context that is too often missing from other accounts — noting how many Indigenous peoples fled the violent Indian Wars in the United States to seek refuge in Canada. He sets up Canadaâ€s restrictions on Chinese immigration in a wider context, noting the anti-Chinese sentiment in places all over the Pacific world from Australia and New Zealand to Japan and the United States. When Macdonald was forced to adopt restrictions to assuage pressure from British Columbia, Canadaâ€s restrictions were more lenient than elsewhere. While other scholars go seeking out the few words Macdonald spoke about the issue and moralize about their racist nature, Dutil actually tries to understand why Macdonald said what he did and how it fits in with what we know about both Macdonald and the world in 1885.

With any luck, many will read Dutilâ€s book. It could begin to undo some of the harm that has been done. A good place to start would be to dig some of those statues out of storage — and name or rename schools in his honour. And if any mob comes to deface Macdonaldâ€s statues this time, they ought to be forced to read Dutilâ€s book — and then clean up the mess they make. Being forced to continuously clean the Macdonald statue and shine the stone or bronze would be a fitting punishment.

National Post

Christopher Dummitt is a historian of Canadian culture and politics at Trent University and a senior fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute.

Article content

Share this article in your social network



Source link

Previous Post

How a Creative Workplace Culture Fuels Business Growth | Entrepreneur

Next Post

Joe Bidenâ€s overdue missile consent for Ukraine

Related Posts

Trump says he's withdrawing the nomination of Musk associate Jared Isaacman to lead NASA

Trump says he’s withdrawing the nomination of Musk associate Jared Isaacman to lead NASA

June 1, 2025
6
Wayfarers Chapel may have a new site in Rancho Palos Verdes

Wayfarers Chapel may have a new site in Rancho Palos Verdes

June 1, 2025
6
Next Post
Police and specialists pick up a fragment of a downed Russian missile

Joe Bidenâ€s overdue missile consent for Ukraine

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Family calls for change after B.C. nurse dies by suicide after attacks on the job

Family calls for change after B.C. nurse dies by suicide after attacks on the job

April 2, 2025
Pioneering 3D printing project shares successes

Product reduces TPH levels to non-hazardous status

November 27, 2024

Hospital Mergers Fail to Deliver Better Care or Lower Costs, Study Finds todayheadline

December 31, 2024

Police ID man who died after Corso Italia fight

December 23, 2024
Harris tells supporters 'never give up' and urges peaceful transfer of power

Harris tells supporters ‘never give up’ and urges peaceful transfer of power

0
Des Moines Man Accused Of Shooting Ex-Girlfriend's Mother

Des Moines Man Accused Of Shooting Ex-Girlfriend’s Mother

0

Trump ‘looks forward’ to White House meeting with Biden

0
Catholic voters were critical to Donald Trump’s blowout victory: ‘Harris snubbed us’

Catholic voters were critical to Donald Trump’s blowout victory: ‘Harris snubbed us’

0

50 Cent says he will dissuade Trump from potential Diddy pardon

June 1, 2025
The Straits Times logo

South Korea’s police looking into death of newborn baby on flight from Philippines to Incheon

June 1, 2025
Reform UK and Plaid Cymru vie for gains in Labour stronghold of Wales

Reform UK and Plaid Cymru vie for gains in Labour stronghold of Wales

June 1, 2025
Dubai’s property market enters stabilization phase in 2025, signaling a maturing investment landscape

Dubai’s property market enters stabilization phase in 2025, signaling a maturing investment landscape

June 1, 2025

Recent News

50 Cent says he will dissuade Trump from potential Diddy pardon

June 1, 2025
0
The Straits Times logo

South Korea’s police looking into death of newborn baby on flight from Philippines to Incheon

June 1, 2025
2
Reform UK and Plaid Cymru vie for gains in Labour stronghold of Wales

Reform UK and Plaid Cymru vie for gains in Labour stronghold of Wales

June 1, 2025
4
Dubai’s property market enters stabilization phase in 2025, signaling a maturing investment landscape

Dubai’s property market enters stabilization phase in 2025, signaling a maturing investment landscape

June 1, 2025
5

TodayHeadline is a dynamic news website dedicated to delivering up-to-date and comprehensive news coverage from around the globe.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Basketball
  • Business & Finance
  • Climate Change
  • Crime & Justice
  • Cybersecurity
  • Economic Policies
  • Elections
  • Entertainment
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Environmental Policies
  • Europe
  • Football
  • Gadgets & Devices
  • Health
  • Medical Research
  • Mental Health
  • Middle East
  • Motorsport
  • Olympics
  • Politics
  • Public Health
  • Relationships & Family
  • Science & Environment
  • Software & Apps
  • Space Exploration
  • Sports
  • Stock Market
  • Technology & Startups
  • Tennis
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • Us & Canada
  • Wildlife & Conservation
  • World News

Recent News

50 Cent says he will dissuade Trump from potential Diddy pardon

June 1, 2025
The Straits Times logo

South Korea’s police looking into death of newborn baby on flight from Philippines to Incheon

June 1, 2025
  • Education
  • Lifestyle
  • Technology & Startups
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2024 Todayheadline.co

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Business & Finance
  • Corporate News
  • Economic Policies
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Market Trends
  • Crime & Justice
  • Court Cases
  • Criminal Investigations
  • Cybercrime
  • Legal Reforms
  • Policing
  • Education
  • Higher Education
  • Online Learning
  • Entertainment
  • Awards & Festivals
  • Celebrity News
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Health
  • Fitness & Nutrition
  • Medical Breakthroughs
  • Mental Health
  • Pandemic Updates
  • Lifestyle
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Food & Drink
  • Home & Living
  • Politics
  • Elections
  • Government Policies
  • International Relations
  • Legislative News
  • Political Parties
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Europe
  • Middle East
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Cybersecurity
  • Emerging Technologies
  • Gadgets & Devices
  • Industry Analysis
  • Basketball
  • Football
  • Motorsport
  • Olympics
  • Climate Change
  • Environmental Policies
  • Medical Research
  • Science & Environment
  • Space Exploration
  • Wildlife & Conservation
  • Sports
  • Tennis
  • Technology & Startups
  • Software & Apps
  • Startup Success Stories
  • Startups & Innovations
  • Tech Regulations
  • Venture Capital
  • Uncategorized
  • World News
  • Us & Canada
  • Public Health
  • Relationships & Family
  • Travel
  • Research & Innovation
  • Scholarships & Grants
  • School Reforms
  • Stock Market
  • TV & Streaming
  • Advertise with Us
  • Privacy & Policy
  • About us
  • Contact

© 2024 Todayheadline.co